One of the queens that I really liked was George, originally caught as a swarm in my yard, than moved to a friend in Uniontown, and a split taken back to my yard. That line lived with me for 4 years without treatment and put up good winter stores. This year, the hive was knocked over in the winter and while I put it back together, it died. With 2 suppers full of honey.
Mel had a Q3 nuc with George offspring that made it well through the winter. Mel put the 5 frames in a full size hive this spring. George did not like that, began to fail and Mel saw a supercedure cell. I took that hive to the farm last Tuesday and started feeding it. I gave it a frame of honey, some syrup and a megabee patty. Today, I also added to frames of capped brood with bees. I saw that the supercedure cell was open. I did not see a virgin or brood, but the hive was active and even bringing in pollen. I exchanged the frames with plastic foundation for frames with comb because the hive’s population is too small to draw out combs right now. I will keep feeding this hive until they stop taking the food and in 4 weeks check for brood. Keeping my fingers crossed.
Sounds like you now have a George 3 or 4 from your original George. One of the frustrations is not knowing if each next generation is stronger or weaker than the previous one. Even half sisters with different fathers will be different. I think I had three Sally 2 sisters last year, but only one survived the winter.